Looking at the families discussed in the Lacy article was interesting becuase they were all middle or upper middle class black families living in similar areas. The only difference was that one neighborhood was mostly black, and the other mostly white. It is understandable that some of these families would want to live in the white neighborhood becuase they see that inequality still takes place in the United States today and they want to do whatever they can to give their children the best possible advantages in society so that they will have a better chance of achieving upward mobility.
However, living around and assimilating into white culture also worried many parents who felt their children may lose their sense of African American culture and customs. Socialization is very important in establishing people's values, morals, and ideas about life and parents worried that having their kids go to white schools, join white organizations, and live in mostly white neighborhoods would have some negative affects as well. While they seem to think it will give their kids advantages in society, they recognize the importance of exposing them to many aspects of African American culture as well.
There seems to be this idea that in a way African Americans have two identities: their identity in the white world, and their identity in the black world. In both communities parents acknowledge this divide and the need for knowledge of, and balance between, both cultures. The difference seems to be that some (those living in the white neighborhood) value social equality over socialization with other African Americans, while others (those in the black community) see socialization and the development of certain ideas and values to be more of a priority than geographically placing their family into a more equal and privileged environment. In a way this goes with the conflict of nature vs. nurture: both socialization and social equality are recognized as important factors for success and acceptance in society; however some see a greater chance of opportunity and equality based on their physical environment (nature), while others see socialization by the beliefs and attitudes of those around them (nurture) as the most important factor.
Tuesday, November 15, 2011
Monday, October 17, 2011
Land of the Free?
Most American's will agree that one of our strongest core values is freedom, but as it turns out we aren't really as free as we seem to think. What is freedom? According to Charon freedom is, "...one's ability to control his or her life... To be free means that the individual is active, not passive, is self-directed rather than directed, chooses direction rather than influenced." (pg.110-111) And in American, where another of our strongest core values is capitalism, we are constantly being influenced and directed toward one thing or another.
If we grow up in a certain area, as part of a certain culture, and learn to follow the beliefs and customs of that place that becomes a part of who we are. Sure, we can stop celebrating certain holidays, not pray at dinner, refuse to wear deodorant, etc. - but even if we have freedom over those actions, we will always remember what those things were like. We will always remember that's what we were taught and how we were brought up, and even if we don't keep doing the exact same things, they are still effecting our actions and what we are doing. We may have certain freedoms from the government and the law, but we don't have freedom from things like culture, socialization, and social structure. They are all around us, affecting everything we do and influencing all our decisions, whether we like to admit it or not. There's a reason Americans are different from Chinese people are different from Germans - we all grew up differently and learned different things. This is no different than how someone from Colorado is different from someone in Texas is different from someone in Manhattan. No matter where we are and where we come from, we all have certain sets of ideas and norms that will always be a part of us as a person and play a large role in the decisions we make, the opportunities we are given, the things we are able to accomplish, and the people that we become. The fact that these things have such a strong impact on people and their actions makes it impossible for us to be truly free as a species becuase we are always influenced by some aspect of our society and what it has taught us about life.
If we grow up in a certain area, as part of a certain culture, and learn to follow the beliefs and customs of that place that becomes a part of who we are. Sure, we can stop celebrating certain holidays, not pray at dinner, refuse to wear deodorant, etc. - but even if we have freedom over those actions, we will always remember what those things were like. We will always remember that's what we were taught and how we were brought up, and even if we don't keep doing the exact same things, they are still effecting our actions and what we are doing. We may have certain freedoms from the government and the law, but we don't have freedom from things like culture, socialization, and social structure. They are all around us, affecting everything we do and influencing all our decisions, whether we like to admit it or not. There's a reason Americans are different from Chinese people are different from Germans - we all grew up differently and learned different things. This is no different than how someone from Colorado is different from someone in Texas is different from someone in Manhattan. No matter where we are and where we come from, we all have certain sets of ideas and norms that will always be a part of us as a person and play a large role in the decisions we make, the opportunities we are given, the things we are able to accomplish, and the people that we become. The fact that these things have such a strong impact on people and their actions makes it impossible for us to be truly free as a species becuase we are always influenced by some aspect of our society and what it has taught us about life.
Thursday, October 13, 2011
Inequality in Society
Both readings from this week looked at inequality and the role that it plays in American society. According to Charon social structure and conflicts create a division of labor among individuals. Inevitably this division between individuals then allows the people in power to over time develop a favored position in society from which they recieve many advantages that help them stay on top. Many of the social institutions we have in place also contribute to this inequality by helping to keep the social structure as it is, so that those on top remain there and those underneath them have a very hard time rising into a higher social class. Because of this those with power and prestige often have better resources and more opportunities available to them which makes it even easier for them to be successful and maintain their position in the class that they were born into. I think that examples of this are seen all the time in everyday life especially here in New York City where the population is so diverse with people from literally all over the World making up several different groups. Even with the diverse population though, almost everywhere you look there is a clear hierarchy in place where those at the top have more power, wealth, and control than the working class who's socialization and culture have cause them to see this type of inequality as legitimate and be obedient to the leader in order to accomplish the organization's goals. This not only allows those on top to lead more lavish lifestyles but puts them in a position where they can begin making moves that only continue to benefit their personal well being, even if it is at the expense of others. Although this cycle seems rough, in America where there is a strong emphasizes on capitalism and private ownership this type of inequality and social stratification is an inevitable reality we all must understand and face so that we can do out best to use to our own advantage.
Friday, September 23, 2011
The Code of the Street
I though the way Kubin explained the code of the street was very accurate. There is this certain image you must have and a respect that you must gain when you're out in the streets becuase of this idea that if you act and /or look weak people will take advantage of you. I guess a part of it is human nature, people generally want to be respected or at the top but I don't think it's just that. When it comes to the street violence, crime, and drugs are an everyday thing and I think a lot of people fall into these street groups and follow the whole code: threats, pro-violence, pro-guns, respect, loyalty, etc. mostly for survival. If you're born into that type of life and you grow up around the streets you see that's what you have to do to survive in your environment. The people in that area that are seen as being on top are the ones who are feared - seen as crazy or out of control. No one wants to mess with those people, and so in a way they're just protecting themselves. All of the gang violence and talk of revenge that gets put out there through music only promotes this and keeps this system going.
At the same time, it's a hard situation to solve. This is a huge part of our culture now, especially in big cities like this one. Certain areas just aren't as nice or safe and people have to put up this bad ass image so that they don't get messed with and their loved one's don't get messed with. The music that perpetuates these problems is raking in billions of dollars and despite being about thug life, reaches all different groups - from city kids, to suburban teenagers, and all over the World. I know that these violent lyrics and the importance they place on gaining respect through violence and threats isn't good and contributes to the problem, but at the same time I grew up in California and I grew up liking this type of music - listening to it at school, at home, driving in the car becuase that's what's popular where I was and it's what everybody was listening to. This music is such a huge part of the lifestyle and culture there, and in so many other places that I don't see it going away anytime soon.
It's unfortunate that so much value is placed upon respect through violence in these communities, but unfortunately these ideas, values, moral, and beliefs are a part of what culture is and what makes each one unique.
At the same time, it's a hard situation to solve. This is a huge part of our culture now, especially in big cities like this one. Certain areas just aren't as nice or safe and people have to put up this bad ass image so that they don't get messed with and their loved one's don't get messed with. The music that perpetuates these problems is raking in billions of dollars and despite being about thug life, reaches all different groups - from city kids, to suburban teenagers, and all over the World. I know that these violent lyrics and the importance they place on gaining respect through violence and threats isn't good and contributes to the problem, but at the same time I grew up in California and I grew up liking this type of music - listening to it at school, at home, driving in the car becuase that's what's popular where I was and it's what everybody was listening to. This music is such a huge part of the lifestyle and culture there, and in so many other places that I don't see it going away anytime soon.
It's unfortunate that so much value is placed upon respect through violence in these communities, but unfortunately these ideas, values, moral, and beliefs are a part of what culture is and what makes each one unique.
Friday, September 16, 2011
Portrayal of Women in the American Media
I found both of the articles we read from the Adler book this week to be quite interesting. I especially enjoyed the one that looked at black and white high school girls and how they felt about the images and ideas in the media. I think I found this most interesting because of how well I could relate to these girls and compare my ideas about this issue to theirs.
I definitely agree that the images we have of women in today's media are both unrealistic and usually just overall sexist. Most women can tell that these images on TV and in the magazines are retouched: the models have no wrinkles, blemishes, or lines on their faces, they are extremely thin, their teeth have been whitened, their hair shined and straightened - and it's really not even a real person that we're looking at. The photos have been digitally enhanced to make those people look better and we are all using it as a means of comparison to ourselves and the way that we look when its completely unrealistic that someone could look perfect like that. Even all these rich and famous celebrities need the make up, clothes, lighting, and retouching. That really shows just how unrealistic these images are. Our society/media doesn't even except the supermodels for how they are - they still go in and fix up the pictures to make them look better, and if even these girls aren't seen as being beautiful enough, certainly the rest of us normal girls are nowhere near achieving the media's idea of beauty - because again, it is actually impossible to make yourself look like a magazine ad.
Although the black girls had a more positive outlook on themselves and didn't all feel the need to look like the girls in the magazines, as most of the white girls did, they certainly still look at media images and the other women around them and compare themselves to these other women. Even if they don't want to be just like them, they are still affected by by the way our society portrays women as a whole because we are all affected by it- there's just no way around it. These ideas we've created about women, and accepted as a society, greatly influence not just the way we look at ourselves, but how others see us as well.
Being a white teenage girl here in America I can tell you that I have been raised to believe that a woman's value is placed almost entirely on how she looks. The media has taught us that if we are thin, light skinned, and what they see as "beautiful" we will get much farther in life and unfortunately this is reality. Being a beautiful woman here gets you connections, free stuff, and special treatment. It's like we are indirectly being told that we don't really need work and school and things like that - if we can focus on getting our hair and nails done, on hitting the gym, and getting the right outfit so we can look sexy that that will make our lives better because we will be perfect and so we will get everything we want in life. This is so unfair because not only is it impossible to look this "perfect" way, but even those who are very attractive and get special treatment etc. still don't get everything they want and have perfect lives - no one does, again it's just not realistic. Because of this, we are constantly unhappy with ourselves and how we look and it is crushing the self esteem of the entire population of American women, because we ALL (men, women, and children) perpetuate this, be it intentionally or not. As we continually see these images of women over and over and do what we can to get as close to that as possible so we can be happy and successful here in America, we have sort of manifested this problem ourselves. We all buy into it even though we know it's not realistic - we still go out and buy the hair dye, the lipstick, the handbag, etc. so that we can try to achieve this ideal and in doing so are constantly trying to one up each other to be the most beautiful, and so this system continues because we let it. We now believe that we have to be this way and since we spend our time, money, and thoughts on trying to achieve it even though it is impossible I do not think this vicious cycle will ever really end, at least not here in the United States.
I definitely agree that the images we have of women in today's media are both unrealistic and usually just overall sexist. Most women can tell that these images on TV and in the magazines are retouched: the models have no wrinkles, blemishes, or lines on their faces, they are extremely thin, their teeth have been whitened, their hair shined and straightened - and it's really not even a real person that we're looking at. The photos have been digitally enhanced to make those people look better and we are all using it as a means of comparison to ourselves and the way that we look when its completely unrealistic that someone could look perfect like that. Even all these rich and famous celebrities need the make up, clothes, lighting, and retouching. That really shows just how unrealistic these images are. Our society/media doesn't even except the supermodels for how they are - they still go in and fix up the pictures to make them look better, and if even these girls aren't seen as being beautiful enough, certainly the rest of us normal girls are nowhere near achieving the media's idea of beauty - because again, it is actually impossible to make yourself look like a magazine ad.
Although the black girls had a more positive outlook on themselves and didn't all feel the need to look like the girls in the magazines, as most of the white girls did, they certainly still look at media images and the other women around them and compare themselves to these other women. Even if they don't want to be just like them, they are still affected by by the way our society portrays women as a whole because we are all affected by it- there's just no way around it. These ideas we've created about women, and accepted as a society, greatly influence not just the way we look at ourselves, but how others see us as well.
Being a white teenage girl here in America I can tell you that I have been raised to believe that a woman's value is placed almost entirely on how she looks. The media has taught us that if we are thin, light skinned, and what they see as "beautiful" we will get much farther in life and unfortunately this is reality. Being a beautiful woman here gets you connections, free stuff, and special treatment. It's like we are indirectly being told that we don't really need work and school and things like that - if we can focus on getting our hair and nails done, on hitting the gym, and getting the right outfit so we can look sexy that that will make our lives better because we will be perfect and so we will get everything we want in life. This is so unfair because not only is it impossible to look this "perfect" way, but even those who are very attractive and get special treatment etc. still don't get everything they want and have perfect lives - no one does, again it's just not realistic. Because of this, we are constantly unhappy with ourselves and how we look and it is crushing the self esteem of the entire population of American women, because we ALL (men, women, and children) perpetuate this, be it intentionally or not. As we continually see these images of women over and over and do what we can to get as close to that as possible so we can be happy and successful here in America, we have sort of manifested this problem ourselves. We all buy into it even though we know it's not realistic - we still go out and buy the hair dye, the lipstick, the handbag, etc. so that we can try to achieve this ideal and in doing so are constantly trying to one up each other to be the most beautiful, and so this system continues because we let it. We now believe that we have to be this way and since we spend our time, money, and thoughts on trying to achieve it even though it is impossible I do not think this vicious cycle will ever really end, at least not here in the United States.
Tuesday, September 6, 2011
Sociological Thinking
I found all the passages we read interesting but I enjoyed the Mills chapter the most. It just seemed a little more in depth and thoughtful than the other two, although what I read from both Charon and Colomy were really informative about the study of sociology and what the subject entails, I felt that what I read from Mills was more thought provoking and made me look at my situation and how the ideas he discusses are playing a role in my life.
For example, when he begins looking at the way people are always wanting more - even when they move up, no matter what they have there's always that feeling that they're missing something, that something is unsolved or unfulfilled. In the text Mills says, "Information often overwhelms their capacities to assimilate it. It is not only the skills of reason that they need - although their struggles to aquire these often exhaust their limited moral energy. (Sociological Odyssey, pg.12)" I feel like we see this all the time in everyday life. Especially here in NYC, everywhere you look people are constantly trying to move up in some way. Even if just promoted or starting a new project, people often feel that sense of urgency like they need to complete this task and move on to the next so they can keep getting closer to what they think they're supposed to be doing with their lives, but as Mills is saying if it's not processed correctly, with sociological imagination, it can become overwhelming and exhausting.
I found him to be very thorough when describing this whole idea of sociological imagination where he explains how in order to possess this you must be able to see things for what they are: as either personal troubles or public issues and be able to look at things from both perspectives and understand how they connect to and interact with each other so you are able to handle them appropriately.
For example, when he begins looking at the way people are always wanting more - even when they move up, no matter what they have there's always that feeling that they're missing something, that something is unsolved or unfulfilled. In the text Mills says, "Information often overwhelms their capacities to assimilate it. It is not only the skills of reason that they need - although their struggles to aquire these often exhaust their limited moral energy. (Sociological Odyssey, pg.12)" I feel like we see this all the time in everyday life. Especially here in NYC, everywhere you look people are constantly trying to move up in some way. Even if just promoted or starting a new project, people often feel that sense of urgency like they need to complete this task and move on to the next so they can keep getting closer to what they think they're supposed to be doing with their lives, but as Mills is saying if it's not processed correctly, with sociological imagination, it can become overwhelming and exhausting.
I found him to be very thorough when describing this whole idea of sociological imagination where he explains how in order to possess this you must be able to see things for what they are: as either personal troubles or public issues and be able to look at things from both perspectives and understand how they connect to and interact with each other so you are able to handle them appropriately.
Sunday, August 28, 2011
The American Dream
“The American Dream of being able to succeed regardless of your origins is equally possible for everyone."
Nothing really surprised me about the article "Class in America: Shadowy Lines That Still Divide," but I did find it very interesting. The American class system is always something I've found to sort of strange and complex and while I agree with the article so none of the information was really that shocking to me, I liked the way they broke it all down and had a lot of specific real-life examples and quotations to make their point. I felt like this made it easier to understand and since I agree, and my argument is the same as theirs, it gave me a lot of good facts and statistics that show how the above quotation is not necessarily true.
While this is a nice idea, and one of the things many Americans are most proud of, this whole idea of accomplishing "The American Dream", I do not agree with the statement. I do think that our country provides many opportunities for success and growth but if you are born into a rich, upper class family in America, you will certainly have a better chance at success.
In the United States money and power go pretty much hand in hand and both of these things can have a huge affect on the type of school you go to, the kind of health care you have, the kinds of food you eat, the sort of protection you have, and so much more. If you grow up in a house where you are always provided for and have everything you need you will not need to go out everyday and bust your butt trying to get ahead or trying to make ends meet. You can take all that extra time and do activities that enrich your life - wether it be spiritually, academically, physically, and everything in between. If you have the luxury of having a lot of free time becuase you do not have to do the things that more unfortunate people must deal with on a daily basis, AND you have money to use on extra classes, tutors, better supplies, etc. you have a huge advantage over those who must struggle to get what they need.
Also, the article talked about how women from upper middle class families usually have children when they're around 30, while those in the lower class average at 22 years old. With this, children being born to the upper class women in their 30s have a much greater chance of survival and success than those born to the lower class 22 year old. The upper class women are not only wealthier, with more connections, but since they've been alive longer they are often also more educated and mature which can have a big impact on how they raise their children.
In my opinion there is no question that those who are born into a higher class have it much easier than those who start at the bottom, especially in America - a very capitalistic society where we are taught to fend for ourselves. This makes it extremely difficult for the poor to rise up and surpass those already in the upper class becuase with the way our society is set up the rich often continue to get richer, while the poor keep struggling along. I do believe that ANYONE in America can achieve the American Dream, but I do not think that EVERYONE can achieve it. Someone has to be the janitor, the babysitter, the delivery guy - or our country wouldn't run how it does. Anyone can succeed and rise to the top but there is only so much room up there and people have to fight their way up there or work to stay at the level they're on. There's no question that being born with a head start, being born already at that top tier of society, is extremely beneficial when working toward each individual's idea of the American Dream.
Nothing really surprised me about the article "Class in America: Shadowy Lines That Still Divide," but I did find it very interesting. The American class system is always something I've found to sort of strange and complex and while I agree with the article so none of the information was really that shocking to me, I liked the way they broke it all down and had a lot of specific real-life examples and quotations to make their point. I felt like this made it easier to understand and since I agree, and my argument is the same as theirs, it gave me a lot of good facts and statistics that show how the above quotation is not necessarily true.
While this is a nice idea, and one of the things many Americans are most proud of, this whole idea of accomplishing "The American Dream", I do not agree with the statement. I do think that our country provides many opportunities for success and growth but if you are born into a rich, upper class family in America, you will certainly have a better chance at success.
In the United States money and power go pretty much hand in hand and both of these things can have a huge affect on the type of school you go to, the kind of health care you have, the kinds of food you eat, the sort of protection you have, and so much more. If you grow up in a house where you are always provided for and have everything you need you will not need to go out everyday and bust your butt trying to get ahead or trying to make ends meet. You can take all that extra time and do activities that enrich your life - wether it be spiritually, academically, physically, and everything in between. If you have the luxury of having a lot of free time becuase you do not have to do the things that more unfortunate people must deal with on a daily basis, AND you have money to use on extra classes, tutors, better supplies, etc. you have a huge advantage over those who must struggle to get what they need.
Also, the article talked about how women from upper middle class families usually have children when they're around 30, while those in the lower class average at 22 years old. With this, children being born to the upper class women in their 30s have a much greater chance of survival and success than those born to the lower class 22 year old. The upper class women are not only wealthier, with more connections, but since they've been alive longer they are often also more educated and mature which can have a big impact on how they raise their children.
In my opinion there is no question that those who are born into a higher class have it much easier than those who start at the bottom, especially in America - a very capitalistic society where we are taught to fend for ourselves. This makes it extremely difficult for the poor to rise up and surpass those already in the upper class becuase with the way our society is set up the rich often continue to get richer, while the poor keep struggling along. I do believe that ANYONE in America can achieve the American Dream, but I do not think that EVERYONE can achieve it. Someone has to be the janitor, the babysitter, the delivery guy - or our country wouldn't run how it does. Anyone can succeed and rise to the top but there is only so much room up there and people have to fight their way up there or work to stay at the level they're on. There's no question that being born with a head start, being born already at that top tier of society, is extremely beneficial when working toward each individual's idea of the American Dream.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)